Did you catch our Thin Mint Ice Cream Sandwiches post from yesterday? Yep! It’s Girl Scout Cookie time, and I wanted to re-share these ideas. I mean, Girl Scout Cookies are delicious on their own, right outta the package. But smushing things between 2 cookies. Well. Do I even have to explain how good that is?!
This post is an older one, but I wanted to update it and share it again because every home in America is being hit by the Girl Scout Cookie plague. You don’t wanna miss these……………….
DUN, DUN, DUUUUNNNNN.
Tagalongs Peanut Butter S’Mores.
Ohhhh, yes I did. Boy Howdy! I love smushing things between cookies. So – I hope you enjoy these.
IF you don’t have any Tagalongs, you can actually make Homemade Tagalong Girl Scout Cookies. My friend Andrea at Savings Lifestyle shows you how! Here’s a photo below of her yummy creation and the recipe is so super duper easy!!
Homemade Tagalong Girl Scout Cookie Recipe by Andrea at Savings Lifestyle
Whoops. Let’s try taking this photo again…
Little Man totally got away with that cookie!
You’ll need:
- Girl Scout Tagalongs (or the Homemade Tagalongs recipe link above)
- Regular size marshmallows
- Baking Sheet (unless you’re roasting marshmallows outside)
How to Assemble:
- Either roast your marshmallows outside (if it’s warmer weather) or you can roast them in your oven. Simply place enough marshmallows on an aluminum foil lined baking sheet, to make however many s’mores you want.
- Turn the oven on broil (apprx. 500 degrees).
- Put the pan with marshmallows in the oven and roast until just browned on top. Then pull them out and assemble your Tagalongs or other peanut butter cookie S’Mores.
*I kept my oven door cracked just a bit to keep a very close eye on them. They were ready in just a minute or 2.
**Don’t overbrown the marshmallows. I actually got mine a little bit TOO brown the first time around, but they were still sooooo good and gooey!
Enjoy!
- Tagalongs Girl Scout Cookies (or similar cookie)
- Regular Marshmallows
- Baking Sheet or Roasting Sticks (if roasting outside)
- Place marshmallows on aluminum lined baking sheet and place the sheet in oven on broil.
- Take out just when they're starting to lightly brown.
- Assemble S'Mores.
What are your favorite Girl Scout Cookies? Leave us a comment!! It’s always fun to hear from you!!
If you liked this post, here are some other ideas you might enjoy…
- Fun Breakfast Waffle Tacos
- Thin Mint Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Simple and Incredible Peanut Butter Recipes
- Healthy Kid Friendly Kabobs
- Rainbow Poke Cupcakes
Jenni
Jenni here! I'm the owner and primary blogger here at Sweet Pennies from Heaven. Married to my better half for 17 years and mom to one awesome little boy. We have 2 dogs, Pepper and Izzy. My favorite thing to do is nap. I love sweets and coffee. Sweet coffee.
Follow Me:
the chick behind this blog! I'm your ordinary, everyday wife and mom to an incredible pair of stinky guys! I am a self diagnosed coffee addict with a ginormous sweet tooth, preferably baked goods!! My hope is to help you, teach you, and entertain you on your way to a more thrifty and frugal lifestyle! Along the way, you'll find awesome recipes, great tips, and tons of randomness! We have loads of fun, so ya'll come back now, ya hear?!
Oh those look rich, and delicious! What an easy way to get a yummy s’mores flavor without the mess of a fire though (especially in the winter). We actually aren’t selling girl scout cookies for the first time this year, and this recipe makes me want to go buy some (but my pants are telling me no..lol)
I haven’t had Girl Scout cookies in years. These look sinfully delicious. I used to love the chocolate mint ones and the peanut butter ones the best.
I want some of these now!! I still haven’t gotten my hands on a box of girl scout cookies, and it’s driving me crazy!!
Are you kidding me? I love you so much right now. I want to make these ASAP – they sound AWESOME!!!
What a great idea, Tagalongs are good but this makes them even better. Making smores out of them is amazing.
You know I have never tried these girl scout cookies I always do the thin mints or the samoas now you make me want to try it just this way too.
What an awesome idea! I had heard of using chocolate chip cookies to make S’mores before, but I’ve never really experimented with it!
I love anything to do with Girl Scout cookies – these look amazing!!!
I am sitting here eating icecream that is made from only bananas because I am trying to loose my baby weight……But I might just have to try one of these instead!
I love all the different things you can make with Girl Scout cookies. Or just eat them plain!
I love your method of roasting marshmallows! Those cookies look really good! My son would go nuts if I made those for him
This reminds me of a line from an old television commercial “two great tastes that taste great together.
Those look so good!! I’m really wishing I had a box of Tagalongs right now!
You are like a Girl Scout
Cookie genius!! We just shove our faces full right from the box
Okay, just when I thought Girl Scout Cookies couldn’t get any better, I was wrong! These look absolutely delicious, super easy, and such a fun treat!
Peanut butter s’mores…why didn’t I think of that? These look so delicious!
I never thought of doing the marshmallows in the oven for smores! And using the tagalongs is genius!
I love sweets, but not marshmallows. So I could make these with my kids and not eat any. Perfect!
YUM! I would devour those in just a few seconds. I always do the marshmellows in the microwave, I’ll have to try them in the oven.
I love the idea of making marshmallows that way, that’s way better than holding them over the flame (gas stove) like we sometimes do. And it’s way less messy!
I want to make these right now! They look so good and I love PB!
I didn’t think you could make Tagalongs any yummier, but you so did! I can’t wait to try this out with the kids.
Oh No You Didn’t~ Why wasn’t I at your house when you made these? You’d have seen a lot more blurry hands!!
I love this! What a great, fun idea to incorporate GS cookies. Maybe I love this recipe too much 🙂
These are those G Scout cookies right? Oh to die for… I love those too.
Aww, we didn’t get any Tagalongs this year! We do have Samoas though – wonder if they would make good S’mores?
Oh my gosh those look really good! Genius idea, great recipe.
What a simple and sweet twist on making smores. These look so yummy and this recipe can be used with other type of cookies. Thank you!
That would be such a yummy combination of flavors! Gotta grab a box of tagalongs before the girl scouts stop selling.
Seriously divine. I was our troops cookie mommy and still have quite a few Tagalongs sitting around so I will definitely try this. Thanks for sharing on the Happiness Is Homemade link party for this week!
Oh these look and sound delicious. I am not a fan of smores at all but my family is! Appreciate the recipe idea.
Between these and your thin mint ice cream sandwiches, I sure know how I’m going to blow my diet this week!
These look amaaaaazing. What an innovative idea! 🙂
Thanks for linking up with Spread the Love!
This looks so yummy!! I would love for you to come link it up at Lovely Ladies Linky! We would love to see what other deliciousness you have to share 🙂 http://www.lifewiththecrustcutoff.com/lovely-ladies-linky-link-26/
Mouth watering!! These look great! I am doing a giveaway ($119 value) on my blog and I would love for you to check it out
-Jennie
http://thediaryofarealhousewife.blogspot.com/
A lovely idea – and I am impressed by the sneaky, photo-bombing hand as well! Thanks for joining in with this week’s Parenting Pin it Party xx
I love how this looks yummy and easy! Thanks for sharing
AMAZING! Love it and I am making these for dessert tonight 🙂
Cathy
Jenni- these could be very dangerous!! They look so good! What a great idea… I’ll be trying them very soon:)
Shannon…my family is totally hooked. The idea just sort of came out of the blue. I am so glad I did it….best thing ever! There’s a link to a homemade Tagalongs recipe in the post now. Another blog friend of mine had a post and I linked to it. FUN!!!
They look delicious, I’ve a super sweet tooth and could quite happily eat a few of these right now. Thanks for linking up to Sweet and Savoury, we’d for you to stop by and link up again this weekend!
Oh my goodness! You are making me hungry!
Thank you for stopping by the Thoughtful Spot Weekly Blog Hop this week. We hope to see you drop by our neck of the woods next week!
Glad I am not dieting,lol. Another delicious recipe with GS cookies. I do like Tagalongs! Thanks for linking up to the Thoughtful Spot Blog Hop. Hope to see you next week!
Tagalons are my favorite Girl Scount cookies EVERRRR! Love them. And I have a thing for marshmallows, too…so in my book, this is the smartest idea ever and you win the internet!
Thanks for linking up to Wordy Wednesday! Pinning these bad boys.
Yay Carrie!!! I cannot believe I WON the internet!!! LOL!! Best prize EVER!